Conversation
Contributor
There was a problem hiding this comment.
代码评审报告: chore: SEO, GEO
风险等级: 低
处理建议: 评论
决策摘要: 纯文档/元数据变更,无运行时代码改动,可安全合并;唯一需要确认的是 README 中对外可见的具体页面选择器与实际脚本实现是否一致。
级联分析
- 变更符号: 无(仅 Markdown、issue 模板、文档)
- 受影响流程: 无运行时流程;影响仓库展示、SEO/GEO 发现路径和兼容性证据收集流程
- 变更集外调用方: 无代码调用方。README 引用
courseGrabber.js、docs/zhengfang-university-coverage.md、docs/github-metadata.md、.github/ISSUE_TEMPLATE/compatibility-report.md,链接均指向本 PR 新增或既有文件 - 置信度: medium(无代码图谱;diff 自洽,但 README 中引用的选择器需对照真实脚本验证)
问题发现
- [低] README 公布的页面选择器需与脚本实现保持一致
- 证据: README 新增 “当前脚本依赖正方页面中的课程卡片结构(例如
.panel-heading.kc_head与input[name="kch_id"])”,但本 PR 不包含courseGrabber.js,无法在 diff 内验证这两个选择器是否与实际代码匹配 - 受影响调用方/流程: 用户据此判断页面兼容性;若选择器与脚本不符,会产生误导性的“是否兼容”判断
- 最小可行修复: 合并前对照
courseGrabber.js确认这两个选择器确为脚本实际依赖;若已实现差异,更新文档措辞
- 证据: README 新增 “当前脚本依赖正方页面中的课程卡片结构(例如
行级发现
- [README.md:27] 公布的选择器
.panel-heading.kc_head与input[name="kch_id"]未在本 PR 内可验证;合并前对照courseGrabber.js确认与实现一致,避免给出错误的页面兼容性判断依据。
Karpathy 评审
- 假设: 文档假设
courseGrabber.js确实依赖 README 列出的选择器;该假设无法在本 diff 内验证。证据分层(A/B/C)设计清晰,明确区分“客户关系”与“脚本实测”,降低了过度宣称风险。 - 简洁性: 文档结构合理,证据等级表与提交要求清晰,无过度抽象。
- 结构质量: 纯文档变更,无代码耦合或复杂度引入;plans/specs 文档自带验证步骤(
git diff --check、placeholder 扫描)。 - 变更范围: 范围聚焦于发现性与兼容性证据,符合 PR 标题 SEO/GEO 意图;README 标题/介绍/FAQ/CTA 改动均服务该目标,无无关重构。
- 验证: 无代码可测试;文档内列出的核验来源链接和官方客户名单准确性依赖人工核对,属可接受的非阻塞剩余风险。
缺失覆盖
- 无代码测试需求。剩余非阻塞验证项:(1) 对照
courseGrabber.js确认 README 公布的选择器;(2) 人工核对docs/zhengfang-university-coverage.md中 23 个客户 Logo 与官方来源链接的准确性,确保不出现过度宣称。
| - **正方官网公开高校客户**:正方官网展示该校为客户,但这不等于该校的选课页面与本脚本兼容。 | ||
| - **本项目社区实测**:提交了学校、系统版本或页面特征、脚本版本、日期及结果的报告;只有这一层可以称为“本脚本已实测”。 | ||
|
|
||
| 运行前请在选课页检查是否能看到课程卡片和教学班信息。当前脚本依赖正方页面中的课程卡片结构(例如 `.panel-heading.kc_head` 与 `input[name="kch_id"]`);若页面结构不同,请先提交脱敏兼容性报告,而不要直接提高请求频率。 |
Contributor
There was a problem hiding this comment.
公布的选择器 .panel-heading.kc_head 与 input[name="kch_id"] 未在本 PR 内可验证;合并前对照 courseGrabber.js 确认与实现一致,避免给出错误的页面兼容性判断依据。
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
No description provided.